領域、論辯立場與論辯方式對知識探究技能與科學認識論的影響

The Effects of Domain, Argument Stand and Dyad Collaboration on Knowledge Inquiry Skills and Epistemological Understanding of Science

檔案

日期

2010

類型

補助單位

行政院國家科學委員會

計畫編號

NSC99-2511-S009-003

語言

中文

摘要

Construction of scientific knowledge relies critically on the application of a set of
knowledge inquiry skills and the understanding of scientific epistemology. Central to
scientific epistemology is the understanding that all knowledge is constructed by humans
and is subject to multiple interpretations and errors, and consequently, method of knowing is
critical to account for the validity of knowledge constructed. Scientific method is, so far,
considered the most reliable method for obtaining reliable knowledge because in scientific
inquires, one’s theory must be falsifiable, and the method to falsify a theory is by appealing
to counter-evidences. Argumentation is therefore an important skill in scientific inquiry.
Argumentation requires that one must take a position regarding a controversial issue,
examine theories and evidences in accordance to one’s own position, and examine theories
and evidences that are inconsistent with one’s position and respond to them. A claim can be
retained only if it can remain intact after vigorous argumentation. Because argumentation
involves coordination of evidence and theory, and refutation and falsification between
proponent’s view and opponent’s view, we predict that argumentation practice can be an
effective method for enhancing students’ knowledge inquiry skills and also enhancing their
understanding of scientific epistemology. In the present study, we will manipulate college
students’ argument stand (proponent vs. opponent), argument method (individual vs. dyad),
and domain (science vs. technology) in argumentation practice to see which kinds of
argumentation design are effective for enhancing knowledge inquiry skills and scientific
epistemology. Our prediction is that, practicing argumentation under dyad condition while
taking an opponent stand will put people in a falsification task so that they have to be critical
about the certainty of the claim posited in a science or technology issue, it therefore would
lead to greater effect in enhancing participants’ knowledge inquiry skills and scientific
epistemology, relative to other design. The study will be divided into 3 separate experiments
and will be completed in 3 years.

所屬典藏

研究計畫
顯示完整詮釋資料 統計資料

引用此條目

洪瑞雲, & HORNG RUEY-YUN (2010). 領域、論辯立場與論辯方式對知識探究技能與科學認識論的影響. https://ir.lib.nycu.edu.tw/handle/11536/100477

BibTeX RIS

引用文字依 APA 第 7 版格式自動產生,使用前請再核對。

分享

永久網址:https://ir.lib.nycu.edu.tw/handle/11536/100477