標題: 分析蔡明亮《不散》從第25個鏡頭到第39個鏡頭:照亮暗黑影像的邊緣與考掘影片差異的晦義蒙太奇
Analyzing Shot 25 to Shot 39 in Tsai Ming-Liang's Goodbye, Dragon Inn: Illuminating the Dark Margin of Images and Excavating Obtuse Montage of Filmic Differences
作者: 劉永晧
Yung-Hao LIU
關鍵字: 蒙太奇;間隙;晦義蒙太奇;黑暗邊緣;維托夫;巴特;阿岡本;迪迪.于貝爾曼;Montage;interval;Obtuse Montage;Dark Margin;Vertov;Barthes;Agamben;Didi-Huberman
公開日期: Jun-2024
出版社: 國立陽明交通大學出版社
National Yang Ming Chiao Tung University Press
摘要: 本論文分析蔡明亮《不散》(Goodbye, Dragon Inn)中的第25個鏡頭到第39個鏡頭,總共15個鏡頭作為影片分析的對象,藉此論證這15個鏡頭所開創新的電影蒙太奇的思維。本論文從過往電影研究中攝影機的30角度拍攝規則、正反拍,平行剪接和交叉剪接的方式,所形成兩個異質系列的剪接型式,以科學方法來逐一檢視它們的差異,加以釐清並論證,在《不散》中的這15個鏡頭,與過往的電影剪接形式上的根本差異,以及美學上的不同,證明它們的特殊性。筆者從維托夫(Dziga Vertov)的「間隙蒙太奇」(Theory of Intervals)電影理論中,去接近蔡明亮這段影片的剪接思維的可能性,找出它們彼此互相呼應的精神。本文再從羅蘭.巴特(Roland Barthes)對於晦義影像(l'obtus)的思考,並且提出晦義蒙太奇的可能。最後,筆者從迪迪.于貝爾曼(Georges Didi-Huberman)探討見證的思維,及阿岡本(Giorgio Agamben)的黑暗邊緣(Dark Margin)的想法,作為影片分析研究的方法,來分析蔡明亮《不散》中此一特殊的蒙太奇剪接思考,以及這15個鏡頭所帶來的新可能,與這15個蒙太奇對於台灣電影站在電影院黑暗邊緣處的特殊見證。
This paper analyzes the 25th shot to the 39th shot in Tsai Ming-liang's Goodbye, Dragon Inn. By using these 15 shots as case study, this paper aims to argue that in Goodbye, Dragon Inn, Tsai intends to create a new possibility in cinematic editing. Borrowing from Dziga Vertov's concept of theory of intervals and Roland Barthes's thinking of sens obtus, in this paper I try to connect the similarities and differences in various fundamental editing and montage principles, in order to develop a new possible path toward the concept of "obtuse montage". And finally, I analyze these 15 shots by adopting Georges Didi-Huberman and Giorgio Agamben's ways of thinking, and reflecting on what these 15 shots in Goodbye, Dragon Inn could provide in montage theory and cinematic aesthetics in future film studies.
URI: http://dx.doi.org/10.6752/JCS.20246_38.0007
http://hdl.handle.net/11536/162999
ISSN: 1816-0514
DOI: 10.6752/JCS.20246_38.0007
期刊: 文化研究
Router: A Journal of Cultural Studies
Issue: 38
起始頁: 131
結束頁: 179
Appears in Collections:Router: A Journal of Cultural Studies


Files in This Item:

  1. Router-2024-38-7.pdf

If it is a zip file, please download the file and unzip it, then open index.html in a browser to view the full text content.